|
A few comments on frequent trading of mutual funds
According to the Investment Company Institute, the mutual fund industry's trade association, for the twelve months from July 30, 1999 to July 30, 2000, approximately 42% of assets in the average stock mutual fund were bought or sold, meaning only a bit more than half the money in the fund actually stayed put for that period. That is up from approximately 40% turnover for the 12 months prior. Some retirement plan experts believe some of this fast trading is occurring in 401k plans.
According to most academic studies, frequent trading of mutual funds to squeeze out a few percentage points of gain a bad idea. Studies confirm what has been suspected by professional money managers for years---namely, frequent mutual fund trading usually hurts long-term returns.
As reported in the Wall Street Journal, one recent study* by University of California, Davis assistant professor Terrance Odean and professor Brad Barber found that investors who traded mutual funds most frequently had the worst returns for a five-and-a-half year period ending December 1996.
During that period the average household earned an annualized return of approximately 15.3% from their mutual fund investments. Frequent mutual fund traders earned an average annualized return of only 10% for the same period.
One of the helpful features of Advisors 401(k) is that it
tends to restrain frequent mutual fund trading by less-sophisticated investors, while at the same time allowing virtually limitless trading of stocks, bonds and funds by more sophisticated investors. How? With
Advisors 401(k) you can offer your employees
a choice of top-name mutual funds and in the same
plan offer self-directed brokerage accounts. Trading
mutual funds requires the employee to submit an updated enrollment application for
processing; the self-directed brokerage accounts are accessed directly by employees
without the need of an enrollment form.
*Source: Wall Street Journal, September 22, 2000, Lucchetti, Aaron, "Frequent Trading Worries Fund Firms."

|